Best Pizza in Magnolia, TX: 8 Pizzerias by Style

The best pizza in Magnolia, TX comes in more styles than you might expect from a small Montgomery County town: four-pizza flights at WanderCrust Pizza Company on Commerce Street, wood-fired pies at Brick & Brews on Tamina Road, Chicago-style thin crust at Crust Pizza Co., and New York slices at Russo’s New York Pizzeria on FM 1488. Eight Magnolia pizzerias made this list, and each one was checked as open on its own website or official ordering page.

Here’s the line to remember: in Magnolia, you don’t have to pick one pizza. At WanderCrust, a “flight” is four small pies with different toppings, so the whole table gets a taste of everything.

How we define Magnolia: this guide covers pizzerias with a Magnolia, TX mailing address in Montgomery County (ZIP codes 77354 and 77355). That includes the City of Magnolia around Commerce Street and old FM 1488, plus the unincorporated FM 1488, FM 1774, FM 2978, Hardin Store Road and Tamina Road areas that carry Magnolia addresses. It does not include The Woodlands, Tomball, Pinehurst or Conroe; for those, see our guides to pizza in The Woodlands and pizza in Conroe.

The quick list

• For a pizza flight and a glass of wine: WanderCrust Pizza Company, 312 Commerce St.
• For wood-fired pizza with a family story: Brick & Brews, 32907 Tamina Rd.
• For Chicago-style thin crust: Crust Pizza Co., 13371 FM 1488.
• For a foldable New York slice: Russo’s New York Pizzeria, 11840 FM 1488.
• For Sicilian squares and slices by the piece: Brothers Pizza Express, 6531 FM 1488.
• For a lunch buffet and an indoor playground: Pizzaiolo’s Gourmet Pizza, two Magnolia stores.
• For a personal pie with unlimited toppings: MOD Pizza, 13650 FM 1488.
• For late-night delivery: Marco’s Pizza, two Magnolia stores.

How we chose

Every pick had to show current hours, a live menu or working online ordering on its own website or official ordering page as of November 2026, with an address inside the boundary above. We sorted them by style so you can choose by craving. Two national chains are included because they fill real gaps, a late-night delivery slot and a fast personal pizza, not because they’re the most interesting pies in town.

Hours below are what each pizzeria typically posts. They change, so check the official site before you go.

Pizza flights: WanderCrust Pizza Company

WanderCrust Pizza Company in downtown Magnolia is the place to go when your group can’t agree, because it serves pizza as a flight of four small pies.

WanderCrust Pizza Company and Detour Wine Bar

Downtown Magnolia, 312 Commerce St. · flights, specialty pies and a wine bar

WanderCrust serves pizza as a flight: four mini pizzas, each with different toppings, instead of one big pie. You can also build your own flight from the styles you want to try. Husband-and-wife owners opened it in June 2024 in a historic building on Commerce Street, with a family-friendly dining room downstairs and a 21-and-up rooftop.

What to order: a build-your-own flight, so everyone at the table picks one pie. Afterward, walk down Commerce Street to Lone Pint Brewery, a Texas craft brewery in downtown Magnolia.

Why it made the list: a family-run pizzeria in the old town center that makes indecision the point. More pies are in our best pizza in Houston guide.

Where can you get wood-fired pizza in Magnolia?

For wood-fired pizza in Magnolia, go to Brick & Brews on Tamina Road, a small brick-oven pizzeria with 13 Texas beers on tap, next door to the Saturday farmers market.

Brick & Brews

Tamina Road area, 32907 Tamina Rd., Suite E · wood-fired brick oven · pizza Wednesday to Saturday

Brick & Brews bakes 12-inch pizzas in a wood-fired brick oven, using its house-made, hand-tossed dough. It sits in what it calls the Culinary Courtyard, next to the Saturday farmers market on Tamina, and it says many of its ingredients come straight from that market.

The “I didn’t know that” moment: the pizza called The Lucca is named for a family story. Brick & Brews says one of its owners’ grandfathers emigrated from Lucca, Italy, to Galveston and opened Pucci’s Cafe there in the 1930s.

What to order: The Lucca (marinara, fresh mozzarella, gorgonzola, spicy salami and basil) or The Pig & Fig (fig jam, prosciutto, arugula and Texas honey). The menu lists 13 Texas beers on tap and a long wine list.

Know before you go: Brick & Brews is typically closed Sunday and Monday. Tuesday is wine and boards only, and full pizza service runs Wednesday through Saturday evenings, with a Saturday lunch window too.

Chicago-style thin crust: Crust Pizza Co.

Crust Pizza Co. on FM 1488 is Magnolia’s pick for Chicago-style thin crust.

Crust Pizza Co. Magnolia

FM 1488 near H-E-B, 13371 FM 1488, Suite 100 · Chicago-style thin crust · open daily

Crust Pizza Co. bills itself as the home of Chicago-style thin crust pizza. Its Magnolia store page puts it off FM 1488 near H-E-B, and it typically opens at 11 AM daily, closing at 9 PM Sunday through Thursday and 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

The insider detail: Crust says its cheese is shredded from the block at each location every day, never bought pre-shredded, and its dough is made in-house several times a day.

What to order: a specialty pie such as Big Dons, Carl’s King or Wyatt’s BBQ, or Madelyn’s Alfredo if you prefer a white pizza. Craving a thicker style instead? Our guide to Detroit-style and deep-dish pizza in Houston covers the other end of the spectrum.

Where do you get New York-style pizza in Magnolia?

For New York-style pizza in Magnolia, Russo’s New York Pizzeria on FM 1488 serves big, foldable slices and square Brooklyn-style pies, and Brothers Pizza Express sells slices by the piece plus Sicilian squares.

Russo’s New York Pizzeria

FM 1488, 11840 FM 1488, Suite B6 · New York and Brooklyn-style · open daily

Russo’s New York Pizzeria has been making New York-style pizza since 1978, according to the brand, which says it cooks only with extra virgin olive oil imported from Sicily. The Magnolia store typically opens at 11 AM every day and closes at 9 PM, or 8 PM on Sundays.

What to order: a New York-style cheese slice, which Russo’s describes as oversized, thin and foldable, or the Grandma’s Pie, baked on a square Brooklyn-style crust with basil, mozzarella, garlic and marinara. Feeding a crowd? The brand menu lists a 28-inch Giant Brooklyn-Style Cheese Pizza. Gluten-free and vegan options are on the brand menu; prices vary by location.

Brothers Pizza Express

Eastern FM 1488, 6531 FM 1488 · slices, Sicilian squares and calzones · closed Mondays

Brothers Pizza Express is the neighborhood slice shop on this list. Its online menu sells cheese, deluxe and meat lovers slices by the piece, a full line of Sicilian square pies, and a pepperoni roll that comes sliced and ready to eat. Most pies start with what the menu calls Brother’s Famous Sauce.

What to order: two slices for a quick lunch, or the Sicilian Spinach, Tomato and Garlic (olive oil, spinach, tomato, garlic and mozzarella) for the table. Brothers is typically open Tuesday through Sunday, from 11 AM (noon on Sunday) into the evening.

Which Magnolia pizzeria is best for kids?

Pizzaiolo’s Gourmet Pizza is the easiest Magnolia pizza night with kids: both Magnolia stores have an indoor playground and a daily lunch buffet.

Pizzaiolo’s Gourmet Pizza

Old Magnolia, 18304 FM 1488, and Hardin Store Road, 28920 Hardin Store Rd., #300 · family-run · lunch buffet

Pizzaiolo’s is a family-run local chain that began in 2015, and its original store is on old FM 1488 in Magnolia. Both Magnolia locations say they run a lunch buffet every day from 11 AM to 2 PM, and the Hardin Store Road location adds a Thursday night buffet from 5 to 9 PM. Both have an indoor playground, and the Hardin Store Road store also has a party room.

What to order: the Pizzaiolo’s Special (pesto, chicken, Kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, portobello mushrooms and cherry tomatoes) or the Shrimp Scampi pizza with garlic butter sauce. You can choose hand-tossed or thin crust, and the menu says to ask about gluten-free pizza. More family picks are in our kid-friendly restaurants in Houston guide.

Who delivers pizza late in Magnolia?

Marco’s Pizza stays open latest of the pizzerias on this list, and MOD Pizza is the fastest way to a personal pie with as many toppings as you want.

MOD Pizza Magnolia West

FM 1488, 13650 FM 1488, Suite 500 · build-your-own personal pizzas

MOD Pizza builds individual pizzas to order with more than 30 ingredients for one price. The Magnolia West store typically opens at 10:30 AM daily and stays open until 10 PM Sunday through Wednesday and 11 PM Thursday through Saturday.

What to order: a loaded personal pie, then the CinnaMOD, a cinnamon-sugar dessert with salted caramel.

Marco’s Pizza

FM 2978, 32725 FM 2978 Rd., and Jordan Lewis Way, 13774 Jordan Lewis Way · delivery and carryout

Marco’s Pizza has two Magnolia stores. The FM 2978 store typically stays open until 11 PM Sunday through Thursday and until midnight on Fridays and Saturdays, later than any other pizzeria on this list, with delivery, carryout and online ordering.

Save this: a Magnolia pizza day

Plan it for Wednesday through Saturday, when every stop is typically open.

1. 11 AM to 2 PM: lunch buffet at Pizzaiolo’s on old FM 1488 in town, especially with kids in tow.
2. Afternoon: walk Commerce Street in downtown Magnolia, with a stop at Lone Pint Brewery if you’re of age.
3. Dinner: a Texan Flight at WanderCrust on Commerce Street, or a wood-fired Lucca at Brick & Brews on Tamina Road.
4. Late: Marco’s on FM 2978 for a delivery pie back at the house.

Magnolia pizza checklist

• Brick & Brews serves pizza Wednesday to Saturday only; Tuesday is wine and boards.
• Brothers Pizza Express is typically closed Mondays.
• Pizzaiolo’s lunch buffet runs 11 AM to 2 PM daily; Thursday night buffet is at the Hardin Store Road store only.
• Need gluten-free? Brick & Brews, Pizzaiolo’s and Russo’s list it; ask the others.
• Check hours on the official site the day you go.

More pizza and food near Magnolia

Making a morning of it? Start with our best brunch in Magnolia guide. Heading on to the lake? See our Lake Conroe weekend guide. For more pizza on the north side, try our guides to pizza in Spring and pizza in Cypress.

Last verified: November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Where can you get pizza flights in Magnolia, TX?

WanderCrust Pizza Company at 312 Commerce St. in downtown Magnolia serves pizza flights of four mini pizzas with different toppings. You can also build your own flight from the styles you want to try.

Is there wood-fired pizza in Magnolia, TX?

Yes. Brick & Brews at 32907 Tamina Rd. in Magnolia bakes 12-inch pizzas in a wood-fired brick oven, with pizza service typically Wednesday through Saturday. It is closed Sunday and Monday.

Where can I get New York-style pizza in Magnolia?

Russo’s New York Pizzeria at 11840 FM 1488, Suite B6, serves oversized, foldable New York-style slices and square Brooklyn-style pies, and it is typically open daily. Brothers Pizza Express at 6531 FM 1488 sells slices by the piece and Sicilian square pies.

Which Magnolia pizza places are good for kids?

Pizzaiolo’s Gourmet Pizza has an indoor playground and a daily 11 AM to 2 PM lunch buffet at both Magnolia stores, 18304 FM 1488 and 28920 Hardin Store Rd. The Hardin Store Road store also has a party room.

What pizza place is open latest in Magnolia, TX?

Marco’s Pizza at 32725 FM 2978 Rd. typically stays open until 11 PM Sunday through Thursday and midnight on Fridays and Saturdays, the latest of the pizzerias in this guide. Check its official page for current hours.