Houston Astros Could Find Value in Newly Available Backup Catcher

The Houston Astros may have an unexpected opportunity to upgrade their catching depth after a recent non-tender decision around Major League Baseball. As teams trimmed their payroll commitments ahead of the deadline, several serviceable veterans hit the open market. One of them, catcher Andrew Knizner, stands out as a potential fit for the Astros as they look to strengthen their roster for 2025.

Houston’s front office has emphasized depth and experience at premium defensive positions. Because of that strategy, the club is expected to explore value signings that support its core players and ease the workload on its starters. Knizner checks many of those boxes thanks to his reliable defense, growing offensive consistency, and familiarity with handling veteran pitching staffs.

Why a Backup Catcher Matters for the Astros

The Astros have long relied on strong defensive catchers, but the depth behind their projected starter has raised questions. Adding a steady, low-cost option would help stabilize a position that often carries heavy in-season demands. Furthermore, Houston’s catchers faced high workloads last year, and the club appeared thin when injuries surfaced.

Knizner, who was non-tendered after the 2024 season, has earned praise for his game-calling and clubhouse presence. While his offensive numbers have fluctuated, he produced stretches of solid contact and situational hitting. For a team aiming to extend its competitive window, those traits carry significant value.

How Knizner Would Fit in Houston

Houston’s pitchers benefit from catchers who communicate well and manage game plans effectively. Knizner’s experience with playoff rotations and diverse pitching staffs suggests he could transition smoothly. His presence would also give the Astros a second catcher capable of starting multiple games per week without sacrificing defense.

While the free-agent market includes several veteran catchers, Knizner offers a blend of affordability, experience, and upside. Because he is just entering his physical prime, he could grow into a larger role if needed. That flexibility appeals to an Astros team managing payroll while staying in contention.

What This Means for Astros Fans

• The team could secure a dependable catcher without a major financial commitment.
• The move would help stabilize a thin position heading into the season.
• Fans would see an experienced defender working with the pitching staff from Day 1.

What’s Next

The Astros are expected to survey the catching market over the coming weeks. If the price aligns with the team’s budget, Knizner could quickly become a prime target. Houston has made similar value-driven signings in recent years, and this situation fits that pattern.

As spring training approaches, the focus will shift to building a roster capable of returning to the postseason. Adding a proven backup catcher would bring stability to a key position and support Houston’s goal of competing deep into October.

This article is a summary of reporting by Sports Illustrated. Read the full story here.