Houston Astros Linked to Potential Trade of Top Prospect Jacob Melton for Veteran Starter

A new round of speculation has emerged around the Houston Astros, as a recent Sporting News report suggests the team could explore trading top outfield prospect Jacob Melton for a mid-rotation starter. The rumored target is a veteran right-hander owed roughly $13 million next season who finished 2024 with 163 strikeouts. While the report does not confirm active talks, it outlines a scenario analysts see as increasingly realistic as the Astros aim to bolster their pitching depth.

The discussion comes as the Astros enter what could be a pivotal offseason. After battling inconsistency throughout 2024, Houston’s rotation showed moments of promise but also exposed a lack of reliable depth behind Framber Valdez, Justin Verlander, and Hunter Brown. With injuries stretching the staff thin, front-office leaders now face decisions that could reshape the roster for several seasons.

Why This Rumored Trade Is Gaining Traction in Houston

Melton, ranked as the Astros’ No. 2 prospect, has drawn praise for his speed, power projection, and defensive value. Even so, Houston’s crowded outfield picture could make him a movable piece should the right pitching upgrade become available.

The Sporting News report argues that dealing from a position of prospect strength might be the Astros’ most realistic path to acquiring a durable starter. The rumored pitcher—a mid-rotation arm who logged more than 160 strikeouts last season—would give Houston an innings-eater capable of stabilizing the rotation after a year marked by uncertainty. Because the team already carries several high-salary veterans, adding a reliable arm with a manageable one-year salary could fit within budget constraints.

For fans across Houston, the idea of moving a top prospect may create mixed reactions. The Astros have leaned on young talent in recent years to offset payroll obligations. However, the team’s championship window remains open, and many analysts emphasize the importance of upgrading the rotation while stars like Kyle Tucker, Yordan Alvarez, and Valdez remain in their prime.

What This Could Mean for the 2025 Astros

If Houston does pursue this type of trade, the move would signal a commitment to competing at a high level in 2025. An additional starter would reduce pressure on developing arms and protect the bullpen from excessive early-season usage. It could also give the Astros flexibility should Verlander require careful workload management.

While no trade is imminent, the idea fits a pattern. Houston’s front office often targets cost-effective pitchers with strikeout upside and solid durability. A player with a track record of 150+ innings and strong strikeout numbers matches that model.

What’s Next

The Astros will likely explore multiple paths to improve the rotation, including trades, short-term free-agent deals, and internal development. Melton’s name will continue circulating in rumors, although Houston typically avoids dealing top prospects unless the return is substantial.

Fans can expect rumors to intensify as the Winter Meetings approach. If the Astros decide to invest heavier in pitching, a deal involving Melton could become one of the offseason’s most significant storylines.

This article is a summary of reporting by Sporting News. Read the full story here.