Best Pizza in Atascocita, TX: 7 Pizzerias by Style

The best pizza in Atascocita comes down to the job you need done. For a sit-down New York pie, go to Brooklyn Pizzeria on West Lake Houston Parkway or Italiano's on FM 1960 East. For late-night delivery, Marco's on Atascocita Road and Papa Johns on FM 1960 East stay open until midnight or later. This guide covers seven pizzerias, all inside Atascocita and all confirmed open on their own websites.

Here's the line worth repeating to a neighbor: when the Brooklyn Pizzeria family moved to Houston, the ovens from its original New York store came too, and the company still brings in ingredients from New York every week. That New York pedigree is on West Lake Houston Parkway, no drive into the Loop required.

Where is Atascocita, for this guide?

Atascocita is the unincorporated lakeside community in ZIP code 77346, east of the city of Humble. For this guide it runs from US 59 (I-69) and the Humble city limits east to the shore of Lake Houston at the FM 1960 bridge, north along Atascocita Road and West Lake Houston Parkway, and south to Will Clayton Parkway. Almost every pizza place here sits on one of three roads: FM 1960 East, Atascocita Road or West Lake Houston Parkway.

We left out pizzerias in Humble proper, on the FM 1960 Bypass, and in Kingwood across the lake. Those have their own guides: best pizza in Humble and best pizza in Kingwood.

The quick list

• For a New York pie at a table: Brooklyn Pizzeria, 19121 West Lake Houston Parkway.
• For a Sicilian square and a full Italian dinner: Italiano's, 8146 FM 1960 East.
• For gluten-free or vegan pizza: Pepperoni's, 12235 Will Clayton Parkway.
• For a picky eater: MOD Pizza, 7011 FM 1960 East, where you build your own.
• For 1 a.m. on a Saturday: Marco's Pizza, 7203 Atascocita Road.
• For delivery any night until 1 a.m.: Papa Johns, 7591 FM 1960 East.
• For a quick carryout: Domino's, 7036 FM 1960 East.

How we chose

We searched the whole of Atascocita for pizza, then kept only places whose own website, or official ordering page, showed a current address in the area in November 2026. We grouped them by the job you need done: a sit-down dinner, a dietary need, a holiday, a late night. Locally owned and Houston-born pizzerias come first. National chains are here because, in Atascocita, they are the ones that answer the phone after midnight.

We left out places we couldn't confirm on an official site, including some older Atascocita pizza names that still show up in directory listings. Hours change often, so treat every schedule below as "typically" and check the official site before you go.

New York-style pies you sit down for

Our two favorite sit-down pizza dinners in Atascocita are both New York-style: Brooklyn Pizzeria for a classic hand-tossed pie, Italiano's for a pie alongside a full Italian menu.

Brooklyn Pizzeria (Atascocita)

19121 West Lake Houston Parkway · typically open daily 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.

Brooklyn Pizzeria opened its Atascocita shop on West Lake Houston Parkway on August 19, 2015; the company numbers it Location No. 3. The kitchen hand-tosses every pie, makes its sauces to order and grates its own Wisconsin whole-milk mozzarella. The company says it brings in ingredients from New York every week, including the olive oil and tomatoes, and when the family moved to Houston, the ovens from its original New York store came too.

It works like a neighborhood pizzeria should: order at the counter, pick a table, and the food comes to you. There are high chairs and a kids' menu.

What to order: a hand-tossed New York cheese or pepperoni pie, sized to the table. The 12-inch cauliflower crust is an option, but the restaurant warns that gluten cross-contact is possible.

Insider tip: Brooklyn Pizzeria runs its own delivery team from this shop. It covers Atascocita from Beltway 8 up to Kingwood, and across Lake Houston into Huffman. It closes on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day and closes early on Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve. Details at bkpizzeria.com.

Italiano's (Atascocita)

8146 FM 1960 East · typically 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday to Thursday, until 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday

Italiano's sits on FM 1960 East just west of the bridge over Lake Houston. It's a family-owned Italian restaurant that opened here in 2011 after its original Humble location became popular. Pizza is one part of a long menu that runs through lasagna, manicotti, chicken marsala and shrimp scampi.

The pizza menu offers a hand-tossed round and a Sicilian deep dish baked as a 16-by-16-inch square. Huffman residents cross the bridge for it, as the restaurant itself points out.

What to order: the X-Large Sicilian square with the meat combination (Canadian bacon, pepperoni, sausage and hamburger) to share, plus a pasta for anyone not in a pizza mood.

Best for: a team party or a birthday. The large enclosed patio can be reserved as a private dining room. See italianosrestaurant.net.

Pizza for gluten-free and vegan diners

If someone at your table eats gluten-free or vegan, Pepperoni's is the Atascocita pizzeria that builds its menu around both.

Pepperoni's Pizza

12235 Will Clayton Parkway, Suite 8 · call (281) 713-5557 or check the official ordering page for current hours

Pepperoni's is a Texas New York-style pizza company. Founder Ray Salti and his family opened the first one in 1990, and it now has more than 20 locations. The company lists this one as its Atascocita/Humble store, on Will Clayton Parkway at the southern edge of Atascocita.

Two details set it apart. Pepperoni's says it works with DiNapoli Brand Tomatoes to grow and harvest the California tomatoes in its sauces. Its dough is made from untreated flour that is never bleached or bromated. It also partners with brands to offer gluten-free and vegan options.

What to order: a New York-style pepperoni pie for the table, plus a gluten-free or vegan pizza for whoever needs one, and a side of wings. See pepperonis.net.

Build-your-own for picky eaters

MOD Pizza is the easiest pizza stop in Atascocita when everyone wants something different.

MOD Pizza (Atascocita)

7011 FM 1960 East · typically 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m., until 11 p.m. Thursday to Saturday

MOD makes individual pizzas to order in a few minutes. You choose from more than 30 toppings and pay one price, however many you pile on. It's the fix for a family where one child wants plain cheese and another wants jalapeños and pineapple.

What to order: one pizza each, built your way, and a salad to split.

Late-night and delivery

For pizza after 11 p.m. in Atascocita, your options are Marco's, Papa Johns and Domino's, all on FM 1960 East or Atascocita Road.

Marco's Pizza (Atascocita Road)

7203 Atascocita Road · typically 10:30 a.m. to midnight, until 1 a.m. on Friday and Saturday

Marco's on Atascocita Road does delivery, carryout and dine-in, and stays open until 1 a.m. at the weekend. It's the late-night pie for the northern half of Atascocita.

What to order: a large pepperoni or one of Marco's specialty pies for the house.

Papa Johns (FM 1960 East)

7591 FM 1960 East · typically 9:30 a.m. to 1 a.m., seven days a week

Papa Johns on FM 1960 East keeps the longest regular hours of any pizzeria in this guide: delivery and carryout from 9:30 in the morning to 1 a.m. every day of the week. It's the safe bet for a Tuesday night when everything else has closed.

What to order: a large pepperoni for the house, ordered for delivery so nobody has to drive at 12:30 a.m.

Domino's (FM 1960 East)

7036 FM 1960 East, Suite A-1 · typically 10:30 a.m. to midnight, until 1 a.m. on Friday and Saturday

Domino's on FM 1960 East is the quick carryout option in the middle of Atascocita's shopping strip, handy when you're already out running errands.

What to order: whatever's on the current carryout deal, picked up on your way home.

Save this: an Atascocita pizza cheat sheet

Screenshot this list for the fridge or the family group chat.

1. Friday family dinner: Brooklyn Pizzeria, West Lake Houston Parkway. Order at the counter and grab a table.
2. Big group or team party: Italiano's on FM 1960 East. Book the enclosed patio.
3. Gluten-free or vegan guest: Pepperoni's on Will Clayton Parkway.
4. Kids who can't agree: MOD Pizza on FM 1960 East.
5. Midnight on a Saturday: Marco's on Atascocita Road, open until 1 a.m.
6. 1 a.m. any night: Papa Johns on FM 1960 East.
7. Delivery across the lake to Huffman: Brooklyn Pizzeria's own drivers cover it.

Tips for ordering pizza in Atascocita

• Know your road. FM 1960 East holds most of the pizzerias here. Brooklyn Pizzeria is up West Lake Houston Parkway, Marco's is on Atascocita Road, and Pepperoni's is down on Will Clayton Parkway.
• Plan the holidays. Brooklyn Pizzeria closes on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day and closes early on Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve, so check hours before a holiday order.
• Order ahead on game nights. Friday nights during high school football season get busy, so call early.
• Make a day of it. Pick up a pie and take it to the lake. Our things to do in Atascocita guide covers the parks and water, and Lake Houston Wilderness Park is a short drive.

More places to eat in Atascocita

If you're not in a pizza mood, start with our best restaurants in Atascocita, then try Mexican and Tex-Mex in Atascocita or brunch in Atascocita. Our Atascocita area page collects everything we've written about the community, and living in Atascocita covers neighborhoods and commutes. For pizza across the rest of the city, see our best pizza in Houston guide.

Last verified: November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I get New York-style pizza in Atascocita?

Brooklyn Pizzeria at 19121 West Lake Houston Parkway and Italiano's at 8146 FM 1960 East both serve New York-style pizza in Atascocita. Pepperoni's on Will Clayton Parkway also makes New York-style pies.

What pizza places in Atascocita are open late?

Papa Johns at 7591 FM 1960 East typically delivers and does carryout until 1 a.m. every day. Marco's Pizza at 7203 Atascocita Road typically stays open until midnight, and until 1 a.m. on Friday and Saturday.

Where can I get gluten-free or vegan pizza in Atascocita?

Pepperoni's Pizza at 12235 Will Clayton Parkway offers gluten-free and vegan options. Brooklyn Pizzeria has a 12-inch cauliflower crust, but warns that gluten cross-contact is possible, so it isn't suitable for anyone who must avoid gluten.

Does any Atascocita pizzeria deliver to Huffman?

Yes. Brooklyn Pizzeria's Atascocita shop on West Lake Houston Parkway runs its own delivery team, and its delivery area extends across Lake Houston into Huffman.

Where can I get Sicilian square pizza in Atascocita?

Italiano's at 8146 FM 1960 East in Atascocita bakes a Sicilian deep-dish pizza as a 16-by-16-inch square, alongside its hand-tossed round pies.